Rub on your primer, then dab foundation on your face and blend it out with a brush, extending down and blending with the skin on your upper neck. Using your fingers, rub concealer under your eyes or on any spots, then brush on some powder to help the makeup set.
Your eyes will be pretty dramatic, so you can either keep the contouring subtle or use it to enhance the witchy look even more.
Squeeze some paint onto a palette or paper plate and use a soft makeup sponge to dab it onto your face, blending as you go. Apply it as close as you can to your hairline, onto your ears if they’ll be exposed, and down your neck and chest to meet the neckline of your dress or shirt. Leave your eyelids bare, since you’ll be doing a smoky eye look later. Dab away the excess paint afterwards with a fresh sponge.
Can’t figure out where to contour your cheeks? Pull a “fish face” to make your cheekbones pop and apply your eyeshadow.
Brush some matte black eyeshadow onto the top of your eyelid and follow the crease line out. Then, use a green eyeshadow to blend it out into your green face paint, towards your nose and underneath the the lash line. Choose a bright green shadow for the main part of the lids and apply with a small brush. Use a black liquid liner to create a thick line just below your lower lashes and above your upper ones. Extend it out into the cat-eye tail and blend it out.
Use your fingers to spread primer on your eyelids up to your eyebrows. Then, rub on a brightly-colored eyeshadow with your fingers, using multiple layers to make the color pop. Try green or purple for a classic witchy look, or experiment with other neon colors. Blend a matte brown eyeshadow into the crease of your eye with a large blending brush, just above the colored eyeshadow. With a smaller, tapered brush, blend a black eyeshadow into the outer corner of your eye and into the crease. To make your colored eyeshadow pop, use a small brush to swipe on white eyeshadow below your brow and along the inner corner of your eye. Apply a black liquid liner along your upper lid, following the crease outwards towards your temple.
You can stick on your prosthetics before your do your makeup, or add them on after and swipe on a bit of extra green paint.
For a non-green witch, you can also use brown eyeliner to define your brows.
Choose a black or purple lipstick for an intense, dramatic effect, or go with a slighter darker shade of green than your main face paint color. You’ll look spooky and witchy either way.